Dedicated to Meaningful Indian Cinema

Art House Cinema

Pune, India · Est. MMXIII

Filmmakers

Amit Masurkar

Role
Filmmaker
Works in
Hindi
On Art House Cinema
No films yet
Portrait of Amit Masurkar

Amit V Masurkar has made three feature films, and each of them watches a person try to do a job properly in a place where nobody wants the job done. He writes as well as directs. Sulemani Keeda (2013) follows two screenwriters in Mumbai who cannot persuade a producer to read their script. Newton (2017) sends a government clerk into the forests of Bastar to conduct one day of polling. Sherni (2021) sends a divisional forest officer after a tigress that has killed villagers. Between the first film and the second the budget changed entirely. The temperament did not.

Black and white portrait of filmmaker Amit Masurkar

Newton carried him a long way out of Versova. It had its world premiere in the Forum section of the 67th Berlin International Film Festival on 10 February 2017 and won the Art Cinema Award of the International Confederation of Art Cinemas. It opened in India on 22 September that year and made money, with collections reported above Rs 17 crore by the first week of October, a figure Nikhil Taneja quoted in Open. At the 65th National Film Awards, announced in April 2018, it was named Best Feature Film in Hindi, with a special mention for Pankaj Tripathi. Masurkar and his co-writer Mayank Tewari won the 2017 Asia Pacific Screen Award for Best Screenplay, at the same ceremony where Rajkummar Rao took Best Actor.

Other honours followed at home and on the festival circuit. The 63rd Filmfare Awards gave the film the Critics Award for Best Film and the award for Best Story. At the 22nd International Film Festival of Kerala in December 2017 it won the FIPRESCI prize and the NETPAC award. Newton was then chosen as India’s official entry for Best Foreign Language Film at the 90th Academy Awards. It did not reach the shortlist.

Masurkar works in Hindi and sets his films away from the cities that Hindi cinema prefers. He shoots on location, casts local performers, and keeps consultants on set for language and for procedure. Gondi and Chhattisgarhi are spoken in Newton by people who grew up speaking them. He came into the industry with no family connection to it. “I’m here with no backing,” he told Open in 2017, “so my biggest prize is that my film is being seen in places like Jagdalpur, Gorakhpur and Solapur.”

Life and Early Work

Masurkar grew up in a middle-class household in Mahim, in central Mumbai, close to Shivaji Park. He was thirty-six when Newton opened in September 2017. Cinema was not part of the house. “I don’t think I’ve watched more than eight-nine movies in a theatre till my 10th standard,” he told Nikhil Taneja. There was no cable television either, because his parents wanted him to study, and by his own account he was not much of a student.

He went to the Manipal Institute of Technology to read engineering. What he found there was not on the syllabus. Around 2000 and 2001 the DVD parlours near the campus were screening Taxi Driver, Reservoir Dogs, Pulp Fiction and Baz Luhrmann’s Romeo + Juliet, and the internet had just reached him. Masurkar watched the films, downloaded their screenplays from Script-O-Rama, and read them against interviews with the directors and whatever making-of material he could find. Taking a film apart and putting it back together is where he dates his interest in craft.

One exchange settled everything else. He came across the blog of Roger Avary, who had shared an Academy Award for the screenplay of Pulp Fiction, and wrote to him for advice. Avary answered. He told Masurkar to believe in what he did and never to keep a backup, and to leave the rest and do films. Masurkar dropped out of engineering at twenty and went home to Mumbai, where, at his parents’ urging, he took a BA in History from Mumbai University for the sake of having a degree.

Entry into the industry came sideways. He covered the Mumbai International Film Festival for the youth magazine JAM, used it to meet people, and landed an internship at MTV Filmy Funda. A decade of assorted work followed. He assisted Aanand L Rai, then making telefilms. He wrote sketches and stand-up material for television’s The Great Indian Comedy Show. He directed a making-of featurette for Dibakar Banerjee and wrote several scripts that were never produced. In 2009 he took the eight-week screenwriting programme at the New York Film Academy in New York.

Then he stopped waiting for a producer to call.

Filmmaking

Sulemani Keeda was made cheaply, produced by Tulsea Pictures in association with Mantra/Runaway Entertainment. Dulal (Naveen Kasturia) and Mainak (Mayank Tewari) are two screenwriters in Versova with an unsold script whose title is Bombay slang for a pain in the backside. Nobody will read it. Their opening comes when Gonzo Kapoor (Karan Mirchandani), the son of a B-movie producer, hires them to write an art film he describes as Tarkovsky with orgies. Dulal then meets Ruma, a photographer played by Aditi Vasudev, and starts to doubt the arrangement. Dilip Prabhavalkar appears as Nene, and Mahesh Bhatt plays himself.

The film went to festivals well before it went to cinemas. It screened at the Mumbai Film Festival in 2013 and travelled to the New York Indian Film Festival, the Indian Film Festival of Los Angeles, the London Indian Film Festival, Zurich and the Oaxaca Film Festival in Mexico, in some venues under the English title Writers. Reviewing it under that name for The Hollywood Reporter, Deborah Young found “much to appreciate in the inventive mise-en-scene and creative editing”, the editing being Khushboo Agarwal’s. PVR Director’s Rare released it in India on 5 December 2014, in Mumbai, Delhi, Bangalore, Pune, Ahmedabad and Kolkata. Forty screens. Rajeev Masand gave it three out of five and called it a charming little indie, and Avary, who saw it at a screening in Los Angeles, sent back a line for the poster comparing it to his early years with Quentin Tarantino.

His next film began while the first was still in the edit. Masurkar was typing words onto a blank screen, and the one that stayed was elections. Producers wanted another slacker comedy from him. He wrote a first draft in 2013 and finished the shooting script with Mayank Tewari after Sulemani Keeda was released, a job of roughly six months.

Reading took longer than writing. The first document he went to was a 2008 Planning Commission report on Left Wing Extremism, and after it Rahul Pandita’s Hello Bastar: The Untold Story of India’s Maoist Movement, Nandini Sundar’s Subalterns and Sovereigns: An Anthropological History of Bastar, 1854-1996, and the work of Ilina Sen. The journalist Javed Iqbal, who had reported from the area, opened his files. Mangal Kunjam, a Gondi journalist and activist from the region, consulted on set and also acted in the film. Masurkar and Tewari spent time in Chhattisgarh with police officers, surrendered Maoists, civil servants, paramilitary personnel, local residents and election officials. A paramilitary consultant and a language consultant stayed with the unit through the shoot.

Money and casting then fell into place with unusual speed. Manish Mundra of Drishyam Films, which had produced Masaan in 2015, heard the film described over a car ride and telephoned Rajkummar Rao, who read the script in two days and agreed to it. Rao later showed a clip to Aanand L Rai, the director Masurkar had assisted years earlier on telefilms. Rai remembered him and rang him up, then came aboard as presenter along with Eros, which turned a planned release of 150 screens into a considerably wider one. Swapnil Sonawane photographed the film, shot entirely on location. Warnings about southern Chhattisgarh came to nothing. Neither the government nor the Maoists bothered the unit, Masurkar told Scroll, because both took them for a harmless Bollywood film crew. The censors passed the film U/A with no cuts.

Reviews in September 2017 were close to unanimous. Shubhra Gupta in The Indian Express called Newton as sharp and subversive as Jaane Bhi Do Yaaro. Rajeev Masand gave four out of five and noted that the film lays on its message too thickly at the end and that the pace occasionally slips. Suhani Singh in India Today also gave four, and Rohit Vats in the Hindustan Times called it one of the finest political satires of recent years. Writing in The Indian Express that October, Harish Wankhede argued that most reviewers had passed over the protagonist’s caste altogether, and read the film as offering a new Dalit hero through a set of quiet social codes rather than a speech.

One charge arrived with the Oscar announcement. Newton was said to resemble Babak Payami’s Iranian film Secret Ballot (2001), in which an election official also collects votes in a remote place. Anurag Kashyap contacted Marco Muller, who had produced the Iranian film, and posted his reply. Payami settled it himself in an interview: “I saw the film and there is no sign of plagiarism. These are completely different films.” The Times of India also reported that Newton was the first Indian film to receive a grant of Rs 1 crore from the central government.

Four years separate Newton from Sherni. Vikram Malhotra produced the third film for Abundantia Entertainment with T-Series, and Vidya Balan took the lead as Vidya Vincent, a divisional forest officer of the Indian Forest Service posted to a district where a tigress has killed people. Shooting began on 3 March 2020 in Madhya Pradesh, in the Delwadi forests of Raisen district, at Kanha National Park and in the forests of Balaghat. Within weeks the COVID-19 lockdown stopped it. Work resumed in October 2020.

What Masurkar came back with is a procedural. Vidya wants the animal tranquillised and moved. The local MLA wants it shot before the polls and brings in a hunter, Ranjan Rajhans, known as Pintu, played by Sharat Saxena. Her own department would prefer no trouble of any kind. Vijay Raaz plays Hassan Noorani, who helps her read the pugmarks, while Brijendra Kala and Neeraj Kabi play officers set above her. Pintu shoots the tigress. Villagers then find the cubs hiding under a log and tell Vidya, quietly, and that is the whole of the victory the film allows her.

Amazon Prime Video streamed Sherni on 18 June 2021, with no theatrical release. Two days earlier the Uttarakhand High Court had declined to stay it. Anna M M Vetticad in Firstpost gave four out of five and wrote that the film delivers “unrelenting yet noiseless excitement”. Saibal Chatterjee in NDTV gave three and a half and called it a worthy follow-up to Newton. Anupama Chopra in Film Companion found the screenplay inert while praising Balan’s restraint, and Bollywood Hungama gave two out of five, complaining of a slow, documentary-like narrative and a bewildering climax. Phuong Le in The Guardian gave three. Balan won Best Actress at the Indian Film Festival of Melbourne in 2021.

Three features in eight years is a slow rate for a Hindi director. Masurkar has said he keeps only one script going at a time, an idea he took directly from Avary’s advice about never having a backup.

The Cinema of Amit Masurkar

One figure recurs. It is the person who insists that the rule means what it says. Dulal will not stay bought for very long. Newton Kumar wants the booth kept open until three o’clock because the manual says three o’clock. Vidya Vincent wants the tigress darted because that is the protocol. None of them wins in the way a protagonist usually wins. Each is left with a fraction of what was asked for, and the price of that fraction is out of all proportion to its size.

Masurkar’s satire never raises its voice. The line that holds Newton together belongs to Sanjay Mishra, on screen for a single scene as an election instructor, who tells the trainee that his problem is not his honesty but the arrogance of it. Imaandaari ka ghamand. The rest of the film tests whether that is a fair charge, and declines to answer.

Comedy here turns without warning. Aatma Singh, played by Pankaj Tripathi, explains the voting machine to Gondi villagers who have been marched to the booth for the benefit of a visiting foreign reporter. He tells them the machine is a toy, that the pictures are of elephants and bicycles, and that they may press whichever one they like. For a few seconds it is funny. Then it is the argument of the whole film, made without commentary and without anyone raising their voice.

Endings interest him more than climaxes do. Newton closes six months on. Mining machinery is working the same ground the election was held on. Aatma Singh, out of uniform, shops with his wife and daughter. Newton sits at a desk in a neck brace from the beating the troops gave him, and when Malko asks what happened after she left, he tells her he will explain over tea in five minutes, once his lunch break has begun. Nothing has been settled and the clerk is still keeping time.

Place is treated as evidence. Newton was shot entirely in Chhattisgarh with Gondi and Chhattisgarhi speakers in the cast, and Sherni inside working forest divisions in Madhya Pradesh. Masurkar first saw Werner Herzog’s Aguirre, the Wrath of God at the Max Mueller Bhavan in Mumbai in 2005 and wanted to shoot in a jungle from then on. He put the difference plainly to Scroll. Aguirre is about power and greed going wild in the deepest of jungles. Newton is about carrying democracy, the loftiest idea of Western civilisation, into the same kind of place.

There is a cost to the method, and Sherni pays it. The second and third films run on one armature, and by the third the machinery shows: an upright officer, a compromised institution, a landscape that will not cooperate, a partial win. Anupama Chopra’s complaint about an inert screenplay is not unreasonable. The film is better on the politics of a forest division than on Vidya herself, who is written as a temperament rather than a person, and the discovery of the cubs arrives with a neatness that Newton would have refused. What survives the objection is the reporting. Nothing else in Hindi cinema has looked as closely at how a divisional forest office actually works.

Key Themes

The dutiful official. Masurkar’s protagonists hold minor posts and no power. A lower-division clerk on reserve duty, a divisional forest officer newly posted. Their authority comes from a manual, and the film’s tension comes from watching how little a manual is worth against a rifle, an MLA or a superior with a transfer order in his drawer.

The distance between the rule and the practice. Democracy in Newton exists as procedure and almost nothing else. Voting machines arrive, forms are signed, the reporter photographs a queue. Whether anyone understands what a vote is remains a separate question, and the film keeps it separate rather than collapsing the two.

Land and what is taken out of it. Bastar and the forests of Balaghat are places where the state’s interest in the ground is not the same as the residents’. Mining follows the election in Newton. Habitat loss and a hydroelectric project sit behind the tigress in Sherni. Masurkar rarely states this. He shows the machinery arriving.

Institutions as comedy. Meetings, briefings, forms and rank are where his jokes come from. Nobody in these films is a villain in the melodramatic sense. Aatma Singh is cynical because he has lost men and cannot get night-vision equipment out of the government, and the closing shots give him a family and a shopping trip.

The local view over the visiting one. Masurkar told Open that a filmmaker has to understand every point of view in a conflict area but keep the view of the people who live there as the dominant narrative. He named Malko, played by Anjali Patil, as the strongest position in Newton. She is the one who tells the clerk that change does not arrive in a day.

Selected Filmography

Sulemani Keeda (2013)

A slacker comedy about two screenwriters hawking an unsellable script through Versova, made on a very small budget and released on forty screens in December 2014 by PVR Director’s Rare. Its interest now is partly documentary: the bedsits, the poetry readings, the producer’s son with money and no taste. It also announced a director who could get performances out of near-unknowns.

Newton (2017)

A black comedy in which a government clerk conducts a single day of polling in a Maoist-affected district of Chhattisgarh, with Rajkummar Rao in the title role and Pankaj Tripathi as the paramilitary officer escorting him. World premiere in the Forum at Berlin, winner of the Art Cinema Award there, Best Feature Film in Hindi at the 65th National Film Awards, and India’s entry for the 90th Academy Awards. The film that made Masurkar’s reputation.

Sherni (2021)

Vidya Balan as a forest officer trying to have a man-eating tigress captured rather than shot, against a hunter, an MLA and her own department. Shot in Madhya Pradesh across a lockdown and released on Amazon Prime Video. Reviews divided over the screenplay and agreed about Balan.

Legacy

Masurkar matters to Hindi cinema out of proportion to the size of his filmography. Newton showed that a researched political comedy set in a conflict zone, with no top-of-the-market star and no song sequence to sell, could open wide and get its money back. Drishyam Films had done something adjacent with Masaan in 2015. Newton went further, into a national award and an Oscar entry, and into cinemas in Jagdalpur, Gorakhpur and Kondagaon, which Masurkar said mattered to him more.

For writers in Mumbai, Sulemani Keeda has a life of its own. It is a film about being unable to get a script read, made by a man who could not get a script read, and it circulated among exactly the people it was about. Farhan Akhtar and Roger Avary both praised it in public. Neither could get it more than forty screens.

The films also widened what a Hindi protagonist could be. Newton Kumar is a lower-division clerk who renamed himself after a physicist, and Wankhede’s reading of him as a Dalit hero was available because the film hands the audience its social codes without a speech. Vidya Vincent is a mid-ranking officer in a green uniform who is called “lady officer” to her face and answers with silence rather than a monologue, a restraint Stutee Ghosh picked out in The Quint at the time of release.

Where Masurkar sits is easier to describe than to rank. He belongs to a line of Hindi filmmakers who use comedy to make a political argument, running back through Kundan Shah’s Jaane Bhi Do Yaaro and the work of Sai Paranjpye, whom he names as a favourite. His method is closer to reportage than theirs. Three features is a small body of work and two of them share a shape, which is a fair thing to hold against him. What holds up is the temperament: unsentimental about institutions, and unwilling to let a tidy ending stand in for an honest one.

Amit Masurkar on Art House Cinema

We haven’t featured a film by Amit Masurkar yet.
We haven’t featured a film by Amit Masurkar yet.