Dedicated to Meaningful Indian Cinema

Art House Cinema

Pune, India · Est. MMXIII

Filmmakers

Chaitanya Tamhane

Role
Filmmaker
Works in
Marathi
Born
1 March 1987Mumbai
On Art House Cinema
No films yet
Portrait of Chaitanya Tamhane

Chaitanya Tamhane has directed two feature films, and both had their premieres at Venice. Court (2014) won the Orizzonti award for best film and the Lion of the Future for a debut feature at the 71st Venice International Film Festival, and went on to take Best Feature Film at the 62nd National Film Awards. The Disciple (2020) played in the main competition at the 77th edition, the first Indian film to do so since Mira Nair’s Monsoon Wedding in 2001. It left Venice with the FIPRESCI prize of the International Federation of Film Critics and the award for Best Screenplay. Tamhane was twenty-seven when Court premiered. He had never attended a film school or assisted a director, and he grew up in a chawl near Century Bazaar in central Mumbai.

Black and white portrait of filmmaker Chaitanya Tamhane

Both films are in Marathi and both are set in Mumbai, though neither sits comfortably inside the commercial Marathi industry around them. Court follows the trial of an ageing Dalit protest singer in a lower court, charged with driving a manhole worker to suicide through a song. The Disciple follows a Hindustani classical vocalist who may never be very good. Tamhane builds his films from long takes, a camera that mostly refuses to move, non-professional performers and sync sound, and he takes years over a script. Court occupied three years from first page to finished print. The Disciple took four.

Recognition abroad came faster than at home. The National Film Development Corporation of India turned down the script of Court for financing in 2012, and the finished film was rejected by Cannes and Locarno before Venice took it. It opened in Indian cinemas on 17 April 2015 across roughly 150 screens and earned almost nothing, an estimated 22,898 US dollars domestically against a budget of 35 million rupees. India then submitted it to the 88th Academy Awards in the Best Foreign Language Film category, where it was not nominated. The Disciple went to Netflix in April 2021 because the pandemic had shut the cinemas.

Between the two features Tamhane spent a year as Alfonso Cuaron’s protege in the Rolex Mentor and Protege Arts Initiative, present during the making of Roma. Cuaron read the script of The Disciple, followed the edit through to the finished film, and took an executive producer credit. Tamhane has also worked on other people’s films, including the Kannada feature Balekempa (2018), on which he was a consulting producer. He is a practising mentalist.

Life and Early Work

Tamhane was born on 1 March 1987 in Mumbai, into a middle-class Maharashtrian household in the central part of the city. His mother took him to Marathi plays, and the wish to perform began there. He wanted to act, because acting was the form nearest to hand. He read literature at Mithibai College in Vile Parle, a college with a busy drama circuit, and it was a man who had directed him in college productions who found him the job that redirected his life.

At seventeen or eighteen Tamhane was writing for Balaji Telefilms, Ekta Kapoor’s television house, on the daily soap Kyaa Hoga Nimmo Ka. The work paid. The company mattered more. Several writers on the floor had trained at the National School of Drama and were at Balaji to make rent, and they passed him films he had not known existed. He spent his salary on DVDs. He has said that the discovery arrived with a second and less flattering one, that a great many of the Indian films he had grown up on were lifted from Western originals.

That second discovery became his first film. Four Step Plan (2005), financed by friends and family, is a documentary on plagiarism in Indian cinema from the 1940s onward. It earned him some press and, more usefully, introductions. One of the people he met while researching it was Anand Gandhi, who in 2009 produced Tamhane’s first full-length play.

Grey Elephants in Denmark traces the life of a magician and mentalist from the age of eight to sixty and carried live interaction with the audience. Vivek Gomber played the lead. The play filled the house at the National Centre for the Performing Arts in Mumbai and was then rarely revived, because Gomber was not available to perform it. Tamhane has trained in magic and mentalism since his teens and calls it his first love. The play gave him two things he would use later. It gave him Gomber, who would produce Court and act in it, and it gave him the conflict he returned to in The Disciple, the pursuit of a secretive and difficult art by someone who may not be equal to it.

Six Strands followed, a short set among the tea estates of Darjeeling, which Tamhane wrote, directed and produced. It was screened at the International Film Festival Rotterdam in 2011, and travelled to Clermont-Ferrand, Slamdance and Edinburgh. The festivals were both a success and a cul-de-sac. Tamhane returned from them without money and without work, unwilling to assist another director and unwilling to take an office job that would, in his phrase, suck his soul. By his own account he was broke and depressed. The idea for Court began in that same year.

Filmmaking

Court started with a television set. Tamhane was watching a conventional courtroom drama on Doordarshan when it occurred to him to make a real one, and he began attending hearings in the lower courts of Mumbai to see what a trial actually looked like. What he found was slow and badly documented. The lawyers, he said in 2014, “were not good orators”, and the arguments were “technical and redundant”. A friend’s afternoon at a police station, spent waiting two hours for a printout because the constable could not connect the printer cable, supplied the register of comedy the film would use.

The political material came from real cases. Jiten Marandi, a cultural activist from Jharkhand, was arrested as a suspect in the Chilkari massacre of 26 October 2007, in which nineteen people were killed, because his name resembled that of a man the police could not find. He was released in 2016. The prosecutions of the singers of the Kabir Kala Manch, accused of links with the far left, fed the narrative as well. Tamhane consulted human rights lawyers, among them Susan Abraham, and read the accounts of manhole workers in a Tehelka book, which gave him the case at the centre of the film. He watched Krzysztof Kieslowski’s 1966 short The Office for reference. Anand Patwardhan’s Jai Bhim Comrade (2011), a fourteen-year project on Dalit protest music, was completed in the same year Tamhane started writing, and he has called it an invaluable resource.

Money came late and in small amounts. Gomber, who had been in Grey Elephants in Denmark, offered to produce and paid Tamhane 15,000 rupees a month to write the script, which took a year. The NFDC said no in 2012. The Hubert Bals Fund of the Rotterdam festival gave 670,000 rupees for script and project development, and Gomber put in the rest of the 35 million rupee budget himself. Accounts of the casting differ. Tamhane has described nearly 1,800 auditions across nine months, while a report in Scroll.in in October 2014 put it at over 2,000 people across eight months. Roughly four fifths of the cast had never been filmed. Tamhane and his crew approached people in banks, railway offices, schools, and at tea and snack stalls, and asked whether they would like to act. The method came from Abbas Kiarostami, whose use of non-professionals Tamhane has acknowledged as the model.

Vira Sathidar, the editor of the radical Nagpur magazine Vidrohi and a human rights activist, was cast as the singer Narayan Kamble three weeks before the shoot. During production the Anti-Terrorism Squad arrived on the set looking for a Naxalite from Nagpur. Sathidar was from Nagpur and politically involved, and the crew hid him, worried that an arrest would leave the film unfinished. The ATS had the wrong man.

The shoot ran 45 days in sync sound. Tamhane and the cinematographer Mrinal Desai, who had come from documentary, used no camera movement and no background score, and shot roughly one scene a day because the takes were long and uncut. Scenes with non-professionals ran to thirty or thirty-five takes on average, and some to sixty. Every location was real except the courtroom, which had to be constructed because filming inside a working court is not permitted. Nothing was improvised. Even the extras loitering at the edge of the frame were placed there. “Everything in the movie was designed,” Tamhane told Scroll.in.

Court premiered at Venice on 4 September 2014 and reached India through the Mumbai Film Festival that October, where it won best film and best director in the international competition and a special jury mention for its cast. The Central Board of Film Certification offered Tamhane a choice between cutting a line of dialogue and muting it. He muted it. Zeitgeist Films took the American rights and the film had its United States premiere at New Directors/New Films in New York on 18 March 2015. The Canadian rights were bought by the documentary maker Ron Mann, who had sat on the Venice jury.

The Indian reviews were strong. Shubhra Gupta gave the film four stars out of five in The Indian Express and called it unmissable. Rajeev Masand wrote of its Kafkaesque absurdity. Meenakshi Shedde, in Mid-Day, located Tamhane’s strength in his even-handedness, in that he humanises the people he also lampoons. Mayank Shekhar called it an anti-genre film and his favourite Indian film of the year.

Research for the second film began in September 2015, five months after Court opened. Tamhane travelled to Delhi, Kolkata, Varanasi, Pune and Ahmedabad, sat in on concerts, and interviewed Hindustani musicians until they trusted him enough to talk about the inside of the practice. Writing started around March 2016. By his account the first page took twenty-two months and the remaining pages two, and the first draft was the final draft. The subject is not the celebrated concert circuit. The Disciple, he told The New Indian Express, is about musicians on the fringes of a Bombay subculture.

Cuaron’s involvement changed the film’s surface. Tamhane wanted something warmer and more subjective than Court, could not find the right cinematographer in India, and asked his mentor for help; Cuaron went to Emmanuel Lubezki, who recommended the Polish cinematographer Michael Sobocinski. Sobocinski spent months in the country before shooting.

Aneesh Pradhan, a tabla player and music historian, curated and adapted the bandishes so that five or six musical sequences could carry the shape of a raga in compressed form. Naren Chandravarkar did the sound design. Rather than record the musicians separately, Tamhane put them in one room together and filmed them with three cameras while they played, so that their reactions during the original recording could be reproduced later on set. Aditya Modak, a classical singer and chartered accountant with no acting experience, was cast as Sharad Nerulkar. Arun Dravid played the guru. Sumitra Bhave, herself a director, gave the recorded voice of Maai, the unseen teacher whose lectures Sharad plays on his headphones as he rides through Mumbai at night. The shoot spread over more than two years. Tamhane edited the film himself.

The Disciple entered competition at Venice on 4 September 2020 and won the FIPRESCI prize and Best Screenplay, then took the Amplify Voices Award at Toronto later that month. The cinemas were shut. The producers sold to Netflix, which released the film on 30 April 2021. On Rotten Tomatoes 96 per cent of 52 reviews were positive; Metacritic recorded a score of 83 from 13 critics. Nick Allen of RogerEbert.com gave it three and a half stars out of four, compared it to Inside Llewyn Davis, and called Modak’s performance incredible. A third feature, developed under the title Who Is Metcena, was selected by the Nipkow Programme in Berlin in 2025 as an India and Mexico project.

The Cinema of Chaitanya Tamhane

Tamhane’s method is subtraction. There is no score in Court and almost no camera movement, and the two devices most Indian films use to tell an audience how to feel are simply absent. What remains is duration. He has described his aim as not abusing time by editing it, wanting instead for the audience to sit inside the scene for as long as the people in it must. The most exact demonstration is the sequence in which the public prosecutor reads a charge sheet aloud from beginning to end. Nothing is dramatised. The state can wait, and so, Tamhane implies, can cinema.

The camera usually sits at the distance of someone in the third row. In Court the framing keeps the viewer outside the emotional life of any single character, and Tamhane has defended the choice on the grounds that ninety per cent of films ask an audience to feel through a protagonist. The distancing, he says, is itself the narrative. In a courtroom that decision has a consequence. The judge and the prosecutor are given the same visual weight as the accused, and the film’s interest turns out to be the machinery rather than the verdict.

Against the coolness of the framing runs a strong comic sense. A speech in Court is interrupted by a man wheeling in a pedestal fan. A public prosecutor discusses the merits of olive oil on the commuter train home, then returns the next morning to ask for a man’s continued detention. The bureaucratic absurdity that critics reached for Kafka to describe is delivered deadpan, and the film is funnier than its reputation suggests.

The Disciple changes the temperature. Sobocinski’s camera drifts, the palette warms, and the film stays close to one man over more than two decades. Sharad rides his scooter through empty night streets with Maai’s recorded voice in his ears, telling him that the true seeker must accept hunger and solitude. He accepts them. He is still not good enough. Tamhane refuses both available endings, the breakthrough and the tragic collapse, and gives Sharad a middle age of digitising archive tapes and a life that is quietly smaller than the one he was promised. That refusal is the film’s hardest and best decision.

Key Themes

Institutions and the people who staff them. Tamhane has said that Court is about the people who comprise the system rather than the system in the abstract, and about failings that belong to any place with a power dynamic. The judge who dismisses a plea on a technicality is later seen slapping a child who wakes him from an afternoon nap on holiday. The guru in The Disciple is an old man with a shrinking circuit of concerts and a pupil he cannot make great.

Vocation and its cost. The magician of Grey Elephants in Denmark, the protest singer of Court and the vocalist of The Disciple all give their lives to a practice that returns very little. Tamhane is drawn to the point at which devotion stops looking like virtue and starts looking like a trap, and he declines to resolve the question in favour of the devotee.

Caste, class and language. The four languages of Court are a social map. Marathi is spoken because the film is set in Maharashtra, the laws are read out in English, the Gujarati defence lawyer is addressed in Hindi because he does not follow Marathi. Baradwaj Rangan noted the contrast between Vinay Vora, who lives alone, drives a car and speaks fluent English, and the prosecutor Nutan, who has a family, takes the train and does not. They meet only in the courtroom.

The sound of a place. Sync sound, recorded on real locations, gives both films an acoustic specificity that is easy to underrate. The hum of ceiling fans and shuffled paper in Court, the tanpura drone and traffic in The Disciple, do the work a score would otherwise be asked to do.

Selected Filmography

Four Step Plan (2005)

A self-financed documentary on plagiarism in Indian cinema from the 1940s onward, made when Tamhane was still in his teens. Its research introduced him to Anand Gandhi.

Grey Elephants in Denmark (2009)

A play rather than a film, and the work that shaped both features. A full-length piece about a magician and mentalist, produced by Gandhi, staged at the National Centre for the Performing Arts with Vivek Gomber in the lead.

Six Strands (2011)

A short set among the Darjeeling tea estates, written, directed and produced by Tamhane. Screened at Rotterdam in 2011, and at Clermont-Ferrand, Slamdance and Edinburgh.

Court (2014)

The trial of the folk singer Narayan Kamble, played by the activist and editor Vira Sathidar, for allegedly inciting a manhole worker to suicide. Winner of the Orizzonti award and the Lion of the Future at Venice, Best Feature Film at the 62nd National Film Awards, and India’s submission to the 88th Academy Awards. Running time 116 minutes.

Balekempa (2018)

Ere Gowda’s Kannada feature, on which Tamhane worked as a consulting producer, part of his involvement in the work of other independent directors.

The Disciple (2020)

Sharad Nerulkar, a Hindustani vocalist in Mumbai, spends twenty-four years pursuing an ideal of purity handed down by his father and by the recorded voice of Maai. Executive produced by Alfonso Cuaron, shot by Michael Sobocinski, edited by Tamhane. FIPRESCI prize and Best Screenplay at Venice, Amplify Voices Award at Toronto.

Legacy

Placing a filmmaker with two features is an awkward business, and Tamhane’s standing rests less on volume than on what the two films did to expectations. Court arrived in the same window as Anand Gandhi’s Ship of Theseus and Hansal Mehta’s Shahid, and belongs with them to a group of Indian films made outside studio structures that found an international audience before a domestic one. Its particular achievement was formal. An Indian film about caste, sedition law and the sanitation workers who die in sewers was made without a single speech asking the viewer to be outraged, and it was more effective for the omission.

The industrial lesson was noticed. Court was financed by an actor friend and a Rotterdam development grant, cast almost entirely from the street, and shot in 45 days for 35 million rupees, and it won at Venice. Younger Marathi and independent Hindi filmmakers have cited that route since. Tamhane has also lent his name to other people’s projects, as consulting producer on Balekempa and as a participant in mentoring and residency programmes, including Berlinale Talents and a Rolex fellowship he took as protege rather than mentor.

There is a reservation worth registering. The rigour that makes Court remarkable also makes it, for some viewers, cold, and the deliberate refusal of identification can read as a director keeping his own hands clean of the politics the film raises. The judge’s holiday coda is a brilliant piece of construction and also a slightly easy one, a final ironic turn that lets the audience leave with a verdict on the man rather than on themselves. The Disciple is the more exposed film precisely because it gives up that safety.

Fifteen years after Six Strands, Tamhane’s output remains small and his method slow by design. The third feature has been in development for years. What the first two settled is narrower than a reputation and more useful. An Indian film could reach the main competition at Venice with an unfashionable subject and a cast of amateurs, and a director with no film school behind him and no family name in the industry could do it twice. He is thirty-nine.

Chaitanya Tamhane on Art House Cinema

We haven’t featured a film by Chaitanya Tamhane yet.
We haven’t featured a film by Chaitanya Tamhane yet.